Wednesday, August 7, 2024

The Lynching That Led To Billie Holiday's Iconic Song "Strange Fruit"

 

Photo By Lawrence Beitler, 1930. Fair Use Image

August 7, 1930, Marion Indiana ─ A White mob attacked the Grant County Courthouse tonight intent on murder. They were reacting to the arrests of three Black teens for the alleged shooting of White man Claude Deeter and raping his fiancĂ©e Mary Ball the night before. Deeter died at the hospital from his gunshot wounds early this morning.

Grant County Sheriff Jacob Campbell had arrested the three African American men that afternoon and had them in jail. By evening word of both the murder of Deeter and the Rape of Ball had spread throughout the county and surrounding communities and White men started coming into town. Many of them had worked with Deeter in the neighboring town of Fairmount. By late evening there appeared to be 1,000 people on the courthouse lawn, and they were in a frenzy.

Although Indiana was a northern state it was no better than most Southern states during the Jim Crow era. There were some 250 “Sundown Towns” in Indiana a reflection of deep-seated racism. In fact, just a few years earlier the state was the power base for the Ku Klux Klan, In 1925 the Klan held most of the political power in the state and had 250,000 members. Although by 1930 the Klan had lost much of that power it wasn’t due to an epiphany by the population regarding their Negro neighbors but a reaction to being affiliated with Grand Dragon David Curtis Stephenson. Stephenson had been convicted of the abduction, rape, and murder of Madge Oberholtzer, a state education official in 1925.

The Sundown Towns then were just a natural outcome of the persistent prejudice in Indiana. The Sundown Town designation was a community where law enforcement and town government agreed on laws to remove anyone who was black (and in many cases Jews Greeks and other Eastern or Southern Europeans) from the town. The core of this White mob seemed to come from the factory town of Fairmount where they had supposedly worked with Deeter, Fairmount was a Sundown Town. The Fairmount crowd was full of White Supremacists.

The lynching of Blacks wasn’t unusual in Indiana either with 21 previous lynchings in the state, so there was fertile ground for racial violence by the night of August 7, 1930.

Word had spread to Indianapolis and Fort Wayne that there would be a hanging that night and apparently, people wanted to be there for the spectacle. By 8:30 that night, the crowd on the lawn was estimated to be more than 5,000 people.

Realizing the intent of some in the crown Sheriff Campbell and all his men stayed at the jail to protect the three Black men in lock up. The crowd did not know that Ball had recanted when asked to identify the men. While the rape of a White woman was probably an even greater reason for a lynching than murder by this time it wouldn’t have mattered the mob was heated and looking for blood.

At 8:30 pm about 20 White men rushed the jail and attempted to break out the men. The sheriff and his men repelled them with tear gas and warning shots.  Word then went out and soon crowbars and sledgehammers were shared, and 200 men attacked the jail breaking down the wall. Thomas Shipp was then pulled free and passed to the mob. Shipp started screaming his innocence as the mob beat him and dragged him to a tree where they strung him up. Abram Smith was taken out of jail the same way. Smith fought back and at one point was able to remove the noose but the crowd further beat him and broke both his arms. 

Then, the mob pulled James Cameron out and took him to the same offending tree, however, someone in the crowd called out, “Take this boy back. He had nothing to do with any raping or killing.” And stunningly the mob released Cameron to the sheriff.

It is believed that both Shipp and Smith were already dead from the savage beating when the mob strung them up from the tree. Some members of the crowd still had not gotten their fill of blood and murder and tried to rally the full crowd to invade the Negro section of Marion and force out the population and burn it to the ground. The arrival of additional police from Indianapolis, Muncie, and Fort Wayne put that idea to rest, as well as the National Guard having been ordered by the governor.

On Aug. 9th a press conference was held, and it was announced that the Sheriff and the Marion Police Chief, two assistant state attorney generals, and Grant County prosecutor would be opening an inquiry to try and find individuals responsible. Also, Flossie Bailey, local NAACP director in Marion, and Indiana Attorney General James M. Ogden worked to gain indictments, but they soon found a conspiracy of silence. The grand jury refused to examine the testimony and brought no charges. 

Survivor James Cameron did go on trial and was convicted for participating in the killing of Claude Deeter and spent four years in prison. At twenty-one, He left prison determined, "to pick up the loose threads of my life, weave them into something beautiful, worthwhile and God-like.” He went on to become an important Civil Rights activist in Indiana. He founded four NAACP chapters and worked for voting rights. His memoir, “A Time of Terror: A Survivor's Story” was published in 1982. Then in 1988, he founded America’s Black Holocaust Museum. He was pardoned by the state of Indiana in 1991 for his participation in the Deeter murder.

James Cameron’s life was not the only legacy of these murders. Lawrence Beitler's iconic photograph of the two swaying bodies sold several 1,000 times in the next week until the police stopped the sale. Beitle's photograph inspired Abel Meeropol, pseudonym Lewis Allan, to write the poem “Bitter Fruit” which he later put to music and renamed “Strange Fruit” which became the signature song of Billie Holiday and has been covered by Nina Simone, UB40, Annie Lennox and others. Strange Fruit became the anthem for the anti-lynching movement and an important part of the Civil Rights movement.

 

Sources:

https://www.abhmuseum.org/an-iconic-lynching-in-the-north/

https://rarehistoricalphotos.com/lynching-thomas-shipp-abram-smith-1930/

https://www.abhmuseum.org/about/dr-cameron-founder-lynching-survivor/

https://www.blackpast.org/african-american-history/marion-indiana-lynching-1930/

https://justice.tougaloo.edu/location/indiana/


No comments:

Post a Comment